Garden City Way
Somewhere along Garden City Road (and presumably near Garden City Pond) should be the ruins of the Garden City Mine. It was our hopes to find these ruins during a drive along the old road early in the fall. Almost too easily we happened across a small poor rock pile along the north side of the road. Poor rock piles mean a nearby mine, and we took a look around to find it. We dropped down from atop the small pile and entered a shaded cedar swamp, sprinkled with a variety of shallow dips and holes in the ground. It was possible that these pot marks were the result of the swampy soil, or they could be subsidence from a mine underneath our feet.
We carefully took a look around and stumbled across an orange pipe exiting from one of these holes. The pipe rose only half a foot from the hole before it took a sharp turn and ran out towards the hole’s edge reentering the ground along the earth wall. The hole seemed square in shape, lined on all sides with remnants of wood boards. Although the floor of the hole was a thick black mud, remains of wooden planks could be seen sticking up from the mud near the holes sides.
While the wooden edges and planks might of suggested what we found was indeed a shaft, we weren’t convinced. This was mostly due to the fact that it wasn’t marked in any way. Almost every mine shaft we found had been marked, either with fallen fences or old signs. This had neither. And even though lots of shafts had an exhaust pipe sticking out of them of some sort, this one looked more like a water pipe. Our theory was that it was an old well or cistern, and not an old shaft.
This was a good start however, and we were sure we would find more ruins now. Fanning out from our find we quickly came to a sprinkling of poor rock scattered along the forest floor. There seemed to be a lot of them along a steep ridge, and on closer inspection we discovered that the ridge was actually another poor rock pile - so old that it had successfully covered by soil and trees. Climbing to its peek we looked out across more of the rock pile, spreading out from a small clearing into the surrounding woods in all directions. The forest had almost reclaimed this pile, and trees were quickly encroaching on the remaining clear areas of the pile.
On one edge of the pile were the items we had been missing before: old metal fence posts and barbed wire. While they had fallen down, they still managed to form a circle around an hollow in the piles edge. This was most likely the shaft, near the rock pile and clearly (somewhat) marked by an old fence. The shaft was alone however, with no other ruins to be found anywhere near the pile. Our only glimmer of hope was an old metal tube that lay on its side in the woods - possibly an old smokestack. Besides that our search only turned up the road as we stumbled out onto it.
Was this the remains of the Garden City Mine? The mine was a minor producer and was in operation way back in the mid 1800’s. The rock pile was defiantly old, and looked similar to the piles found at the North American and Cliff which also were from the same era. The mine was not in operation long enough to probably warrant the erecting of more permanent stone buildings that might be found today. Most likely the buildings were all made from wood and have long since rotten away. There was another mine in the area (the Meadow Mine) and these piles could just as easily belong to that mine instead. We’ll need to return and take a closer look in the area with the leaves and brush down. Maybe we’ll get more answers then.
Loved your site and the work you have compiled. I am a teacher in Ohio. Born and raised in Michigan in the 50’s and 60’s. I love anything about the UP. Taking a motorcycle trip up your way this summer. It would be great to hook up with you and share a cup of coffee.
Jeff TerBush | May 4, 2007
Jeff - glad you enjoy the site. Not much of a coffee drinker I’m afraid, but drop me an email before you come up and we can set something up. At the very least I can direct you to some of the more interesting (and lesser known) spots around here. You can consider me your local guide.
Motorcycling around these parts has become very popular lately. Last summer we couldn’t drive a mile without running into a group of them. It’s probably a great area for it - lots of paved roads, scenic views, and a limited amount of traffic. I’ll just stick to my car however.
explorer | May 4, 2007
Great to hear back from you. I have read every inch of your website. Can’t get enough about iron and copper mining in the UP. I especially like the human interest piece. Day to day hardscrabble existence. The photos of the steel toe and rubber sole was very moving for me. Felt like I was reaching back into time. When I was 10 my Dad and Mom took us down in a iron mine in Kingsford. I have never forgotten that thrill or the trip to Fayette in the Garden peninsula. Also enjoy reading the technical part of the mining process. Stopes, winzes, skips and drifts are all fascinating to me. My grandfather worked as a logger in the LP around Alpena in 1909-1910. My folks are still living and reside in Tuscola county around a little burg called Caro. Good talking to you. By the way, what is your first name?
Jeff
Jeff TerBush | May 14, 2007
My G-G-Grandfather was the Mine Superintendent at the Garden City Mine in Eagle River Michigan during the 1870’s. The house that the mine built for him is still inhabited. The mine ruins are a short distance from the house. It is called the Eagles Nest and I just found out it is on the market. I can give you more info if you want.
John Stephens | August 14, 2007
John..
I figured the mine was somewhere near that house, and we one took a trip along the Garden City Creek looking for it but found nothing. (except pop bottles) I didn’t get too close to the house, since it was obviously private. We assumed the mine was on the opposite side of the stream (to the west of the Eagles Nest). I’d love any more info if you got it, just send me a note through the contact form above. Thanks!
explorer | August 14, 2007